Does a Cold Winter Kill Garden Pests? - Ep. 327
Just Grow Something | Evidence-Based Home GardeningNovember 17, 2026
327
00:30:4728.18 MB

Does a Cold Winter Kill Garden Pests? - Ep. 327

Every winter someone says it. We need a good hard freeze to kill off the bugs. And every mild winter, someone warns that we're in for a terrible bug year. In this episode I dig into what the research says about winter and garden pests.

Most of the insects that bother our gardens are built for the winters where they live, and they spend those months tucked into soil, leaf litter, and plant debris where the air temperature barely reaches them. Snow keeps them even warmer. We'll talk about how insects survive the cold, why a snowless cold snap can do more damage than a snowy one, and what studies on ticks and Japanese beetle grubs found when researchers measured winter survival. Then we'll look at what a warm winter does change, from invasive pests creeping north to insects that wake up too early and starve. And we'll finish with what you can do this fall and next spring, zone by zone, that matters more than the weather forecast.

Let's dig in!

Get a quote for your personalized garden consultation: https://justgrowsomething.com/gardenconsulting

Get your fair-trade, organic coffee and support the show at https://LarrysCoffee.com/JustGrow

Reference and Resources

Just Grow Something: https://justgrowsomething.com Gardening Courses: https://justgrowsomething.com/courses Just Grow Something Merch and Downloads: https://justgrowsomething.com/shop Just Grow Something Gardening Friends Facebook Group: https://www.facebook.com/share/g/18YgHveF5P/ Check out how you can become a patron on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/JustGrowSomething Feed my coffee habit: https://buymeacoffee.com/justgrowsomething Amazon storefront: https://www.amazon.com/shop/justgrowsomething

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

[00:00:00] The first hard freeze very well may have come through your garden by now. It likely looks like a completely different place. The plant leaves that were so big and green maybe just a few weeks ago are now black and slumped over in the row. Hopefully, the annual weeds have died back to the point where you can finally clear them out of the beds. And the squash bugs and the cucumber beetles have finally disappeared for the season, right? So it's tempting to look at that frozen patch and feel a little bit of satisfaction. Finally, the cold is going to take care of those nasty little bugs for us.

[00:00:30] Except, it won't. Those squash bugs aren't sitting out there in the open waiting to freeze. The adults have already crawled down into the plant debris and the leaf litter and the top of the soil and that's where they're going to spend the winter. Down there, it stays a whole lot warmer than the air you and I are standing in. And that is true for most of the pests that we deal with. The insects that bother our gardens are built for the winters where we live.

[00:00:57] A brutal cold snap can knock back a few of them, mostly the ones living out in the open or the newcomers coming in from warmer places. But a cold winter is not going to clean your garden out. And conversely to that, a warm winter doesn't guarantee a bad bug year either. What happens next spring and what you do this fall matter a lot more than what the temperature says in mid-January.

[00:01:24] Welcome back to Just Grow Something. I'm Karin Velez, market farmer, horticulturist, and your friend in the garden. The frost has come for a lot of us and with it comes one of the most common things gardeners or just people in general say every single winter. We need a good cold one to kill off the bugs. First, we'll talk about how insects survive the winter in the first place because once you understand that, the myth sort of starts to fall apart. And then I'll walk you through what happens under the snow and the leaves with some research on ticks and grubs that measured it.

[00:01:54] After that, we'll look at what a warm winter does change because some things really do shift. And then we'll talk about what all of this means in your zone and what you can do this fall and next spring that will make more of a difference than the weather. Let's dig in. Before we get going, if you've been enjoying the show, the single most helpful thing you can do is hit follow in whatever podcast app you use or subscribe if you're watching on YouTube.

[00:02:21] There are a ton of you that listen or watch each week that aren't subscribed and that really does make it easier for you to listen to new episodes as they come out. Please and thank you. And if you love coffee, like I love coffee, you really shouldn't sleep on Larry's Coffee. You can support the show and get a free gift by going to Larry's Coffee slash JustGrow. They also have great gift options available now with bundles that include like a stovetop mokey pot and two bags of their coffee or a pour-over brew kit.

[00:02:50] There's coffee bundles. There's gift cards. That's going to make your gift giving easier this season. Your first purchase over $15 gives back just a little bit to this show. And you or the person you're gifting gets some organic fair trade premium coffee to enjoy. I totally win-win all over the place. Larry's Coffee slash JustGrow. And as always, the link is in the show notes.

[00:03:12] So let's start with where this idea of cold winters equals fewer bugs and warm winters mean more pest pressure comes from because I guess it kind of makes sense on the surface. We feel the cold. We see our tomatoes turn to mush after a frost. So it's natural to assume a bug that's a fraction of the size of a tomato plant would be done for when the temperature drops close to zero. But insects have been dealing with winter for a very long time.

[00:03:41] And the ones that live in your area are the descendants of the ones that made it through every winter before this one. Every insect that spends the winter where you live has some kind of adaptation to local conditions. They wouldn't be there otherwise. And they use a few different strategies. And some of them are actually really amazing. The first one is something called diapause. And diapause is kind of like a planned dormancy.

[00:04:10] The insect's development shuts down. Its metabolism slows way down. And in a lot of species, it becomes much more cold hardy while it's in that state. What triggers diapause for most insects is day length. They're responding to the shorter days of late summer and fall so they get ready for winter on schedule whether the fall is warm or cold. Squash bugs are a good example.

[00:04:33] In a study of squash bugs in coastal Virginia, the adults from the late summer generation entered diapause in late September to early October. By the time we get our first frost, they are already settled in. The second strategy is chemistry. Many insects make their own antifreeze compounds like glycerol, which keep their body fluids from freezing even when the temperature drops well below 32 degrees Fahrenheit.

[00:05:02] Some insects avoid freezing completely by clearing out anything in their gut that ice crystals could form around. They can stay liquid at temperatures far below freezing. Other insects let the water outside their cells freeze solid while protecting the insides of their cells. One of my favorite examples is the goldenrod gallfly.

[00:05:25] If you've ever seen these round marble-sized swellings on goldenrod stems like along the fence row, that's the home of little larvae. That larvae freezes solid in the winter and it can survive temperatures down to about 40 below zero. At 40 below, Fahrenheit and Celsius are the same number so you don't even have to convert. That's just cold, okay? Now, not every insect is that tough.

[00:05:51] Some can't survive freezing at all and they depend on finding a protected spot. Which brings us to the third strategy and this is the most important one for gardeners and that is location, okay? Insects are cold-blooded. Their body temperature matches whatever is around them. That means the wind chill on your weather app means absolutely nothing to them. What matters is the temperature right where they are sitting.

[00:06:18] And most garden pests are not sitting out in the open air. They're under the leaf litter, in the few top inches of the soil, under bark, inside plant stems, or they're tucked into the debris at the edge of your garden. So the insects that spend the winter out in the open on plant stems or under bark have a much greater chance of being hurt by winter conditions than the ones that spend the winter in the ground.

[00:06:44] That is a big deal because a lot of our worst vegetable garden pests are ground dwellers in the winter. Let's run through a few of them. Squash bugs spend the winter as adults under plant debris near usually where the squash grew the year before and they come out of the soil and the ground litter in the spring. Striped cucumber beetles spend the winter as adults also at the edges of fields or in the woods under leaf litter and plant debris.

[00:07:12] Japanese beetles spend the winter as grubs in the soil and they can be up to about 10 inches deep. And ticks, which a lot of you ask about, spend the winter under leaf litter, crop residue, and snow. Every one of those is a hiding spot that stays warmer than the air above it.

[00:07:34] Now, there's one more group worth knowing about and these pests are the reason that the cold winter idea sometimes seems to work. Some of the insects that we deal with every summer don't survive the winter in like the northern part of the U.S. at all. Potato leaf hoppers and black cutworms have to migrate north from the southern states every spring.

[00:08:02] Thrips blow in from the south every spring too. For those pests, your winter makes no difference. Their numbers depend on what the winter was like hundreds of miles south of you and on the winter or the weather that carries them north at the right time. So, what happens under the snow and the leaves? Snow flips the whole myth on its head.

[00:08:28] Snow is a mix of ice and air, and that air makes a surprisingly good insulator. It doesn't pass heat or cold along very well, so it buffers the soil underneath from low temperatures and from big temperature swings. Snow depths of about 4 to 10 inches have been shown to give very effective insulation. And snow cover reduces both how deep and how long the soil freezes.

[00:08:56] So, think about two winters. In the first one, the temperature drops way below zero, but there is a nice deep layer of snow on the ground. In the second one, it gets just as cold, but the ground is bare. Which winter is harder on the insects in your soil? The snowless one, right? Bare soil freezes deeper, and that's what kills more grubs.

[00:09:23] A snowy year with extreme cold has less of an impact than a snowless year with similar temperatures. So, when you see that big snowstorm and think, oh, okay, at least this is going to kill the bugs, it's actually doing the opposite. That snow is tucking them in. Japanese beetle grubs actually give us some numbers to work with.

[00:09:44] To kill Japanese beetle grubs, the soil needs to stay below 32 degrees Fahrenheit for about two months or drop below about 15 degrees in a single event. Soil temperature is the key, and the air temperature can be far colder than the soil. Researchers in Minnesota have tracked how Japanese beetle grubs survive different winters. You have to listen to these numbers.

[00:10:12] In the winter of 2018 to 2019, okay, when the average soil temperature was just under 31 degrees Fahrenheit, about 36% of the grubs survived. Then next winter, when the soil averaged about 33 degrees Fahrenheit, okay, so we're talking two degrees warmer. And for you Celsius people, trust me, two degrees Fahrenheit is not a whole lot.

[00:10:37] Two degrees warmer, 77% survived, okay? And the winter after that, when the soil averaged about 35 degrees, every single grub survived. A couple of degrees in the soil made a big difference. But notice that even in the hardest of those three winters in Minnesota, about a third of the grubs made it.

[00:11:03] A third of a big grub population is still plenty of beetles chewing on your roses next July. Now, let's talk about ticks, because I've been asked about ticks more than anything else. Researchers in Connecticut and Maine buried pots of black-legged tick nymphs, which makes my skin crawl. This is the kind of tick that spreads Lyme disease, right? And they followed them through three winters. Some pots kept their natural leaf litter and snow.

[00:11:32] In others, they raked away the leaves, they shoveled off the snow, or they did both. Now, the ticks with leaves and snow left in place had the best survival, about 59%. When the researchers removed both the leaves and the snow, that survival rate dropped to about 36%.

[00:11:53] So, leaf litter turned out to be the more dependable insulator of the two, because snow came and went, but the leaves stayed put. And the temperature difference was striking. Under the leaves and the snow, the coldest it typically got was just a few degrees below freezing. Out in the open air at those same sites, the lows were in the single digits and the teens Fahrenheit.

[00:12:18] So, the ticks were spending the winter in a spot that was roughly 15 degrees warmer than the air, and sometimes more. Now, another team went even further north into northern Maine to see whether the cold up there is what keeps black-legged ticks from spreading. And they found that the tick survival over the winter in northern Maine was about the same as it was in southern Maine, because the deep snowpack up north kept the ticks buffered from the cold.

[00:12:48] But when they surveyed for ticks, they found about 90 ticks for every 1,000 square meters along the southern coast, about 18 in central Maine, and none at all in inland northern Maine. So, the ticks could survive the winter up there. Something else is keeping them out, and the researchers don't know exactly what yet. They concluded that winter survival isn't the only thing limiting where these ticks can live.

[00:13:18] So, we know the cold isn't doing as much as people assume, but we don't fully know what is. Now, here in Missouri, the tick picture is a warm one, okay? Our average winter temperature has been warmer than average in 8 of the last 10 years. This spring, from the beginning of February through mid-April, temperatures across the state averaged about 8 degrees above normal. Ticks typically get active when it hits about 45 degrees Fahrenheit,

[00:13:47] and they can wake up and go looking for a host on any mild day in midwinter. So, the tick season here is starting earlier and running later into the fall. And what about those squash bugs? This is the one that I most wanted a number for, and I couldn't find one. A thorough review of squash bug biology and management lays out where they spend the winter,

[00:14:11] but it doesn't give any data on how many die over the winter or how cold it has to get. We do know that mild winters let a larger share of the adults survive, but I couldn't find a study that put a number on it. That's unfortunately a real gap for a pest that so many of us fight every single summer. Frost is coming, and when it hits, your garden story for this year is over.

[00:14:37] Before you pull those plants and forget about it, ask yourself what went sideways. The soil? The timing? The pests? I can help you sort it out. In a virtual garden consultation with me, I take a close look at your season and build you a step-by-step plan for next year. Head to justgrowsomething.com slash gardenconsulting to get your quote. The link is in the show notes. That's justgrowsomething.com slash gardenconsulting.

[00:15:08] So if a cold winter doesn't wipe out the bugs, does that mean winter doesn't matter? Well, not quite. Winter weather does make a difference for some insects. It just doesn't always work the way that we expect. Let's start with the cases where a warm winter does help the pests. The biggest one is invasive insects. A cold winter likely isn't going to affect our native insects.

[00:15:34] But invasive species that are pushing into a new area, especially along the edges of where they've already spread, are more likely to be knocked back by a hard winter. Emerald ash borer is a classic example of this. The larvae spend the winter under the bark of the ash trees. And research shows that a significant number of them die when temperatures hit about 30 below zero for a day or two.

[00:16:00] That kind of cold happens in northern Minnesota. It doesn't happen in most of the country, which may be part of why the emerald ash borer has spread more slowly in Minnesota than like in Michigan and Ohio. When the winters are warmer, more of those larvae survive. And the ones that get a longer feeding season can finish their life cycle faster. Corn earworm is another one.

[00:16:29] And this one actually matters for vegetable gardeners because it also goes after tomatoes and peppers. For a long time, the rule of thumb was that corn earworm couldn't survive the winter north of about the 40th parallel, which runs roughly through Kansas, Missouri, Illinois, Ohio, and Pennsylvania. North of that line, the moths had to fly up from the south every year.

[00:16:54] A large research team looked at four decades of soil temperature records and found that the area where corn earworm can survive the winter has grown by about 3% since 1981. And they're projecting that area to roughly double by 2099. And the reason is fewer of the deep killing cold events in the winter.

[00:17:18] So warm winters do let some pests survive further north than they used to. That part of the worry about these temperatures is real. But a warm winter also creates problems for insects. And that side of it doesn't usually come up. Now, when we get a warm spell in January or February, insects that should be dormant can wake up.

[00:17:46] They start moving around and that burns through the energy reserves that they stored up last fall to get them through to spring. But there's nothing to eat yet. No new leaves, no flowers, no squash plants. So if they wake up too many times or they stay active for too long, they can actually run out of fuel and starve before spring ever gets here. And then there's the swing back.

[00:18:09] An early warm spell followed by a sudden cold snap can kill insects that have already become active. That's why a winter that bounces back and forth between warm and freezing can be harder on some insects than a winter that just stays really steadily cold. And remember, a mild winter often means less snow. Less snow means less insulation. So when a cold snap does come, the soil underneath can get colder than it would under a snowy blanket.

[00:18:39] Unfortunately, winter doesn't only affect the pests. It affects the good guys too. Lady beetles, ground beetles, parasitic wasps, and the other predators that eat our pests are spending the winter in the same leaf litter and plant debris. If a harsh winter knocks back the lady beetles, then the aphids may have a better year next summer because fewer predators are around to eat them.

[00:19:03] So when winter hurts the beneficial insects alongside the pests, then the net effect for the gardener is really going to be close to nothing. And then there's the spring itself. The entomologists who study this keep coming back to spring. The weather during the spring, when insects are laying eggs and the young ones are hatching,

[00:19:28] likely matters more to how big their populations get than anything that happened while they were dormant. A cool, wet spring can slow things down. A warm, dry spring can speed things up. So high pest numbers coming out of winter may not cause much damage if the spring weather works against them or if there are plenty of predators around.

[00:19:54] And a small population can still turn into a big problem when those conditions are right. When the 2011 to 2012 winter in Missouri ranked among like the five mildest on record, an entomologist writing for Missouri produce growers took on the question of whether that meant a bad bug year. His answer was that it wasn't clear and that the best thing growers could do was scout carefully.

[00:20:23] Another entomologist that same year compared predicting Japanese beetle numbers in July to predicting the weather in July. Her bottom line was that we probably wouldn't notice a huge difference. I actually find that reassuring. The real answer to whether this winter will mean more bugs is that it depends. And that's why paying attention in spring matters so much.

[00:20:55] Let's bring this down to your garden. Your winter shapes what you can expect. So let's go through it by climate. If your winters are cold, say zones three through five, you're the gardeners most likely to see winter knock back certain pests, especially the ones that are living out in the open or the invading newcomers at the edge of their range. You're also where the migrating pests matter the most.

[00:21:21] If you garden in a place where corn earworm, potato leaf hoppers, or black cutworms don't survive the winter, their numbers each year depend on what happens to the south of you and how early they arrive. But your soil dwelling pests are well protected, especially in years with good snow cover. A winter with little snow and a hard cold snap can be tougher on your grubs at least than a snowy winter with colder air.

[00:21:50] Now, if you're in the middle zones like I am here, so zone six and seven, you are kind of in that stretch where winter can go either way. We get some snow, some bare ground cold snaps, plenty of warm spells in between. That on-again, off-again pattern can be hard on insects that wake up too early. But it's also giving ticks a longer season.

[00:22:16] And it's the region around that old sort of dividing line for the corn earworm where it's starting to survive the winter in places that it couldn't before. On our farm, the squash bugs and the cucumber beetles show up every year, regardless of what kind of winter that we had. So just plan on yours doing the same. And if your winters are mild, you are in zones eight and up, winter is less of a pause and more of a slowdown. A lot of insects stay active through the cooler months,

[00:22:46] and some of your garden pests may never go fully dormant. Aphids are probably the best example of this. In mild winter places like much of California, most aphids reproduce for most or all of the year without mating. A single female can give birth to as many as 12 young per day, and each adult can produce up to about 80 offspring in a week.

[00:23:09] In warm weather, a newborn aphid can grow up and start reproducing in about seven or eight days. If you think that you look at your plant one day and then come back four days later, and it seems like the population has doubled, tripled, exploded in some way, that is why with aphids. With numbers like that, there is no winter reset for you. Your best tools are steady scouting for them, encouraging the predators,

[00:23:37] and catching the problems early all year round, right? And wherever you live, the beneficial insects are following the same rules as the pests. A winter that's easy on the squash bugs is usually easy on the lady beetles and the ground beetles too. So if we can't count on the weather, what can we count on? The good news is that you have more control over this than the thermometer does.

[00:24:04] The first thing is to clean up where the pests live and leave the rest. This is absolutely a balancing act. You have heard me and a lot of other gardeners say to leave the leaves for the beneficial insects, and that is still good advice. Lady beetles, assassin bugs, the minute pirate bugs, syrphid flies, parasitic wasps, these all spend the winter in leaf litter, bark, and plant debris.

[00:24:28] Only about 2% of our known insect species ever cause problems that make people call them pests. Most of what's sleeping in your leaves is on your side or it's just minding its own business. But some pests are very specific about where they spend the winter, and that gives you a target. Squash bugs, they spend the winter near where squash grew this year.

[00:24:54] So the squash and the pumpkin vines, the leftover fruit, any curcubit family weeds, these are all worth pulling out and composting or burying. Clean up is most helpful right after harvest. Removing the plants takes away the food that the late season nymphs need to finish growing out. It also takes food away from the new adults right when they need to build up the body reserves to get them through the winter. So if you can get those squash plants out as soon as you're done harvesting,

[00:25:21] before the frosh does it for you, you're cutting into next year's population. Now I know that's probably too late for most of us, so really the sooner the better. And one thing that doesn't help as much as you would think in this area is crop rotation, at least for things like squash bugs. The adults are strong flyers, so moving your squash to the other side of the garden is not going to help keep them from finding it. Rotation still has plenty of value for like soil and disease, but don't count on it for something like squash bugs.

[00:25:51] Cucumber beetles, they're harder to target because they spend the winter along the edges of fields and in nearby woods, and they're generally under the leaf litter. You probably can't clean that up, and you wouldn't want to because those same spots are sheltering the predators. So for cucumber beetles, your best tools are actually in the spring. Something else that you want to do is rake back the leaves where people walk. Ticks are the exception to the leave the leaves advice.

[00:26:20] Leaf litter helps ticks survive the winter, so we want to rake the leaves away from the places where people and pets spend time, like your pads, your play areas, the edges of the lawn. If your property borders the woods, you can move those leaves deeper into the woods or onto beds where nobody walks. And since ticks can be active any time it warms up, just keep doing those tick checks after your time outside, even in the winter.

[00:26:46] Now, we do want to keep the beneficials habitat, so leave the stems and leaves standing in your native plantings and your flower borders. We went into this in episode 324 with native plantings and the predators that they support. The more predators that come through the winter in your garden, the more help you'll have when the pests wake up. And you want to start scouting early next spring. Whatever kind of winter we get,

[00:27:15] warm spells can bring pests out earlier than you're used to. So don't wait until you see damage. Squash bugs become active during warm spring periods and they fly to the first squash plants or alternate hosts that they can find. Females start laying eggs about a week to 10 days after the overwintering adults come out. In summer squash, one adult or one egg mass per plant is the point where, okay, it's worth taking action for. That's why I'm out there checking every other day once those plants are in the ground.

[00:27:45] The board trap works great in spring too. By the way, if you lay down a board or a piece of cardboard or a shingle or whatever on the ground near your young squash plants, the squash bugs gather underneath overnight. In the morning, you can just flip it over and you can deal with them all at once. You know, some people are using fire, some people are using vacuums, whatever your choice is. Either way, they're all right there for the taking. The other thing is to use row covers really early. Okay, so this,

[00:28:13] I do this as soon as the plants go in the ground or as soon as the seed goes in the ground. Putting a lightweight insect cover over your squash or your cucumbers or whatever right at planting time, that is going to help keep overwintered bugs, you know, the squash bugs, the cucumber beetles off of your young plants. Now, of course, we have to remember that any crop that needs a pollinator is going to have to be uncovered once it starts to bloom, but at least you are excluding them from the very beginning. You are cutting off that food source,

[00:28:40] which is going to start to reduce that population right away. And if you're in a mild winter zone, you're just going to have to make scouting a year round habit. I am sorry. I know that it's extra work, but check the undersides of the leaves on your cool season crops every single week. Give the lady beetles and the lacewings a chance to do their work before you reach for a spray.

[00:29:05] Most of the insects that bother our gardens are built for the winters where they live. They use diapause, natural antifreeze, and protected hiding spots in the soil, under the leaves, and in plant debris where it stays far warmer than the air. Snow makes those spots even warmer. So a cold winter with deep snow is easy on them, but a snowless cold snap is harder. Warm winter does help some pests,

[00:29:35] especially invasive insects and pests like corn earworm that are surviving further north than they used to. But warm spells also wake insects up too early and burn through their reserves, and winter affects the predators right along with the pests. Spring weather often matters more than any of this. So instead of watching the forecast and hoping for a deep freeze, put your energy into the things that you can control. Clean up the squash patch.

[00:30:03] Leave the leaves where the beneficials need them. Rake them back where you walk, and just start scouting early next spring. We don't have to wait on the weather to have a good garden year. We get to be a part of it. Next week, we're heading indoors. We'll talk about growing food inside through the winter months, and which crops are just as easy to grow inside year-round, so you can free up space in the garden for the crops that need it.

[00:30:32] Because, yes, I am already thinking about garden planning for spring. Until next time, my gardening friends, keep on cultivating that dream garden, and we'll talk again soon. We'll talk again soon.